Vaikka Super Bowl pelataan vuodenvaihteen jälkeen, merkataan mestari sille vuodelle, jolloin runkosarja on alkanut. Juuri sekaannuksen välttämiseksi NFL käyttää Super Bowlista järjestysnumeroa eikä vuosilukua.

Super Bowl	Vuosi	Voittaja	Häviäjä	Tulos
XLVI	2011	New York Giants	New England	21-17

XLV	2010	Green Bay	Pittsburgh	31-25
XLIV	2009	New Orleans	Indianapolis	31-17
XLIII	2008	Pittsburgh	Arizona	27-23
XLII	2007	New York Giants	New England	17-14
XLI	2006	Indianapolis	Chicago	29-17
XL	2005	Pittsburgh	Seattle	21-10
XXXIX	2004	New England	Philadelphia	24-21
XXXVIII	2003	New England	Carolina	32-29
XXXVII	2002	Tampa Bay	Oakland	48-21
XXXVI	2001	New England	St. Louis	20-17
XXXV	2000	Baltimore	New York Giants	34-7

XXXIV	1999	St. Louis	Tennessee	23-16
XXXIII	1998	Denver	Atlanta	34-19
XXXII	1997	Denver	Green Bay	31-24
XXXI	1996	Green Bay	New England	35-21
XXX	1995	Dallas	Pittsburgh	27-17
XXIX	1994	San Francisco	San Diego	49-26
XXVIII	1993	Dallas	Buffalo	30-13
XXVII	1992	Dallas	Buffalo	52-17
XXVI	1991	Washington	Buffalo	37-24
XXV	1990	New York Giants	Buffalo	20-19

XXIV	1989	San Francisco	Denver	55-10
XXIII	1988	San Francisco	Cincinnati	20-16
XXII	1987	Washington	Denver	42-10
XXI	1986	New York Giants	Denver	39-20
XX	1985	Chicago	New England	46-10
XIX	1984	San Francisco	Miami	38-16
XVIII	1983	Los Angeles	Washington	38-9
XVII	1982	Washington	Miami	27-17
XVI	1981	San Francisco	Cincinnati	26-21
XV	1980	Oakland	Philadelphia	27-10

XIV	1979	Pittsburgh	Los Angeles	31-19
XIII	1978	Pittsburgh	Dallas	35-31
XII	1977	Dallas	Denver	27-10
XI	1976	Oakland	Minnesota	32-14
X	1975	Pittsburgh	Dallas	21-17
IX	1974	Pittsburgh	Minnesota	16-6
VIII	1973	Miami	Minnesota	24-7
VII	1972	Miami	Washington	14-7
VI	1971	Dallas	Miami	24-3
V	1970	Baltimore	Dallas	16-13

IV	1969	Kansas City	Minnesota	23-7
III	1968	New York Jets	Baltimore	16-7
II	1967	Green Bay	Oakland	33-14
I	1966	Green Bay	Kansas City	35-10

Mestaruudet	Seurat
6	Pittsburgh Steelers
5	San Francisco 49ers Dallas Cowboys
4	Green Bay Packers New York Giants
3	New England Patriots Los Angeles/Oakland Raiders
2	Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts Denver Broncos Washington Redskins Miami Dolphins
1	St. Louis Rams Tampa Bay Buccaneers Chicago Bears Kansas City Chiefs New York Jets Baltimore Ravens New Orleans Saints